Universal 3D printable modular French Cleat

  • Status: Closed
  • Prêmio: $110
  • Inscrições Recebidas: 41
  • Vencedor: draguxconstantin

Painel de Comentários

  • draguxconstantin
    draguxconstantin
    • 4 meses atrás

    It was not one of your requirements for the design: "I'll also need the corresponding end caps designed that slide into the final end pieces of the assembled French Cleat stick - these should have at least 1 screw hole the same as described above. " ? Just asking!

    • 4 meses atrás
  • draguxconstantin
    draguxconstantin
    • 4 meses atrás

    Thank you for grading my design. It was something in particular you was looking for in order to make your design better? Just for myself, to improve my performance in to the future!

    • 4 meses atrás
  • Brennan199
    Proprietário do Concurso
    • 5 meses atrás

    I've extended the contest as there are at least 4 entries being worked on that could benefit from a 5 day extension. Freelancer adds half of the extension fee to the contest total so I believe the total prize should be about $110. I'm thus far impressed with many of the entries. Good luck!

    • 5 meses atrás
  • Vandalit
    Vandalit
    • 5 meses atrás

    hi, youn can give feedback to entry #2

    • 5 meses atrás
    1. Brennan199
      Proprietário do Concurso
      • 5 meses atrás

      There are parts of the design I like but it doesn't connect well along the long axis and it's not reversible unless you are stacking one on top of the other. The part I like about it is that the channeled part in the middle removes material but probably will not adversely affect strength (assuming the wall it's screwed into will strengthen it). This means, for 3D printing, less material is needed to do this design. Overall it's a good design but not what I'm looking for on this project. I'd like to keep in touch though - you are a good designer who is thinking of some things I didn't even ask you to consider (material usage, etc.).

      • 5 meses atrás
    2. Vandalit
      Vandalit
      • 5 meses atrás

      thanks very much for the feedback. Now i get the "half way point of the chamfer".
      I will retake the contest and send you some more proposals through this week.

      Sadly i cant give you a generative design with my actual software (limited for my actual hardware), but if you can get a fusion 360 pro version or an autodesk inventor version (2020 or higher, i have 2015) i can make a design that will fit well with this feature, in a way you just need to import the file.

      I manage the theory of FEA analysis (needed in the generative designs i know, where you put the forces in action), and later, must be just importing and use this automatic feature.

      Greetings

      • 5 meses atrás
  • Vandalit
    Vandalit
    • 5 meses atrás

    or you could upload some draws for the profile?

    • 5 meses atrás
    1. Brennan199
      Proprietário do Concurso
      • 5 meses atrás

      Added a quick sketch of the main profile in the details area for you. I didn't extrude it yet but thus far nobody has connected the segments in a strong way along the longest axis or added holes in the way I've described. Hope that helps.

      • 5 meses atrás
    2. Vandalit
      Vandalit
      • 5 meses atrás

      thanks. help a lot.

      • 5 meses atrás
  • myre007
    myre007
    • 5 meses atrás

    hay can you give feedback for my entries

    • 5 meses atrás
  • Rudolph07
    Rudolph07
    • 5 meses atrás

    mas esquemas para poder conprenderlo desde un principio, y hacer el trabajo una sola vez.

    • 5 meses atrás
  • mecanikad
    mecanikad
    • 5 meses atrás

    Hi. Does it really need to be Fusion ? This will drastically limit the number of freelancer. Fusion is not a very popular CAD software.

    • 5 meses atrás
    1. Brennan199
      Proprietário do Concurso
      • 5 meses atrás

      Doesn't need to be, as long as it can be converted or exported to formats that will work on 3D printing and I have a format that has the parametric data associated with it. I don't want to have to redraw for other sizes in the future.

      • 5 meses atrás
  • Vandalit
    Vandalit
    • 5 meses atrás

    Interesting project, i use to work with Inventor and i am moving to Fusion 360 recently.
    I will make an entry in the next weeks . Greetings.

    • 5 meses atrás
    1. Brennan199
      Proprietário do Concurso
      • 5 meses atrás

      After feedback, I'm accepting other file types as long as they can be converted and still work. Inventor or Fusion - whichever you feel is best for you.

      • 5 meses atrás
  • Rudolph07
    Rudolph07
    • 5 meses atrás

    entiendo como lo quieres, pero no entiendo que quieres en particular. :/
    por cierto, si quieres parametrizar todo y el envío en distintos formatos, deberías subir algo más ;)

    #increaseprize

    • 5 meses atrás
    1. Brennan199
      Proprietário do Concurso
      • 5 meses atrás

      Saving in multiple formats shouldn't be an issue. The description took longer than is would for me to sketch it; I'm mainly farming for better approaches while I test materials on the 3D printer. The last contest at $100 produced two very good results, and I paid the second place $80 for their design. In the future, If I need something more complex, I may consider increasing the prize. Thanks for your honest feedback; it's appreciated.

      • 5 meses atrás
  • Brennan199
    Proprietário do Concurso
    • 5 meses atrás

    Answers & Clarification: 1.) Doesn't need to be in Fusion, but must be in a valid CAD format that can be used in other programs, either by importing/exporting or by converting. 2.) The design is intended to be a mirror along the centre lines (front and back, top and bottom). I'm seeing some designs that will not work in this manner. 3.) The connection MUST be a sliding type along the longest axis; my preference is for at least enough overlap to run a screw through the connection (or optionally a bolt/nut with the inset if it can't be screwed at that point), which adds additional strength. 4.) The French Cleat portion must only go 1/2 way through the thickness (more like a chamfer), otherwise it will not work in the manner I'd like it to, and it needs to work even if installed upside-down. 5.) The screw taper and the inset for a nut must show on both sides of the mounting holes. Again, for ease of use and the ability to mount upside down and still have it function well. Hope that helps.

    • 5 meses atrás
  • Vandalit
    Vandalit
    • 5 meses atrás

    #sealed

    • 5 meses atrás

Principais inscrições deste concurso

Ver Mais Inscrições

Como começar com concursos

  • Publique seu concurso

    Publique seu Concurso Rápido e fácil

  • Receba muitas inscrições

    Obtenha Toneladas de Inscrições De todo o mundo

  • Premie a melhor inscrição

    Premie a melhor inscrição Baixe os arquivos, é fácil!

Poste um Concurso ou Junte-se a nós Hoje!